KeKeep “The Monkey’s Paw” tense instead of turning it into a worksheet marathon. This two-day secondary ELA lesson uses a few deliberate reading stops, then asks students to go back and examine how W. W. Jacobs builds suspense through warning, irony, pacing, Gothic atmosphere, and ambiguity.

“The Monkey’s Paw” works because readers have to wait, wonder, and imagine. This lesson is built to protect that experience.

Across two class periods, students read with minimal interruption. On Day 1, they track Morris’s warnings, Mr. White’s choices, and the consequences of the first wish. The lesson stops after the £200 compensation so students leave with the story still unresolved.

On Day 2, students read the rest of the story, including the knocking sequence, without interruption. Then they rewind the final scene, trace how Jacobs increases tension, and consider the question the story never answers for us: What is actually outside the door?

The ending discussion allows for more than one defensible interpretation. Students have to support their reading with details from the story rather than simply being told that Herbert “comes back as a zombie.”

WHAT'S INCLUDED

• 14-slide editable teacher PowerPoint
• 5-page editable student packet with built-in writing space
• 3-page editable teacher guide
• PDF versions of all three files
• START HERE instructions with a public-domain reading link

SKILLS & CONCEPTS

• Suspense
• Foreshadowing
• Situational irony
• Pacing
• Gothic atmosphere
• Ambiguity
• Theme
• Text evidence
• Defending an interpretation

LESSON FLOW

DAY 1 — MAKE THE WISH

• Quickwrite: Would you use the wishes?
• Reading Stop 1: Morris’s warning
• Reading Stop 2: the £200 wish
• Wish Ledger: warning → choice → result
• Prediction / cliffhanger

DAY 2 — PAY THE PRICE

• Quick reset
• Finish the story without interruption
• Rewind the final scene: second wish → waiting → knocking → final wish
• Interpret what may be outside the door
• Craft lens: foreshadowing, irony, suspense, pacing, Gothic atmosphere, ambiguity
• Short analytical response

TEACHER SUPPORT

The 3-page teacher guide includes pacing, stopping points, discussion notes, likely student responses, and guidance for the ambiguous ending. The student packet includes space for written responses, including a dedicated page for the final analysis.

TEACHING TIME

2 class periods

Designed around approximately 35 minutes of usable instructional time per day; works well in a standard 40–45 minute class period with normal transitions.

BEST FOR

• Grades 8–12
• Short story units
• Gothic literature
• Suspense / horror units
• Foreshadowing and irony lessons
• Close reading
• Halloween or spooky-season literature
• Secondary ELA

Teaching another short classic where the ending changes how students see everything that came before? “The Open Window” is a one-period Saki lesson built around Vera’s deception, the twist ending, and the final line.

Want another two-day atmospheric short-story lesson?

For Use with Strawberry Spring by Stephen King | AP Lit Halloween Case File

Building a Gothic classroom display?

Gothic and Dark Literature Literary Quote Posters

IMPORTANT TEXT NOTE

The text of “The Monkey’s Paw” is NOT included. Use your anthology, textbook, or a legal public-domain copy of the story. A free public-domain reading link is provided in the START HERE instructions.

ANSWER KEY / TEACHER SUPPORT

Teacher guide with suggested responses and discussion notes is included. Open-ended analytical responses will vary.

FILE TYPES

Microsoft PowerPoint (.pptx)

PDF

PAGES / SLIDES

22 total instructional pages/slides:

• 14-slide teacher deck
• 5-page student packet
• 3-page teacher guide

20 total instructional pages/slides:
• 14-slide teacher deck
• 4-page student packet
• 2-page teacher guide